Reversible Transitions Between Continuous and Droplet Regimes in a Thin Water Stream

Author: Atharv Tiwari

Abstract

Thin liquid jets are known to undergo breakup into droplets due to capillary instabilities, most notably described by the Rayleigh-Plateau mechanism. This work reports an experimental observation in which a thin, gravity-driven water stream exhibits spontaneous and reversible transitions between a continuous jet and a discrete droplet regime under carefully controlled conditions. Unlike classical jet breakup, the observed behavior is not monotonic; discrete droplets subsequently re-merge into a continuous stream without external forcing. High-speed video recordings (200 fps, 4K resolution) confirm the repeatability of this transition. The phenomenon appears only within a narrow range of flow rates and environmental stability, which might suggest a self-organized dynamic balance between capillary instability and jet continuity. The results do not contradict established fluid dynamics theory but instead highlight a constrained regime in which reversible jet-droplet transitions may occur.

Keywords: Droplet formation, Capillary instability, Rayleigh-Plateau instability, Thin liquid jet

Introduction

Liquid jets are conventionally modeled as continuous media governed by the Navier-Stokes equations. Under surface-tension-dominated conditions, cylindrical jets are unstable to perturbations and typically fragment irreversibly into droplets, as described by the Rayleigh-Plateau instability. In most textbook treatments, this breakup proceeds in a single direction: from continuity to discreteness. 

However, transient and reversible behaviors may arise when competing physical effects operate within narrow parameter ranges. Motivated by these ideas, the present work investigates whether a gravity-driven water stream can exhibit reversible transitions between continuous and discrete flow regimes without external periodic forcing.

Relevance and Context

Understanding reversible jet instabilities may be relevant for microfluidics, inkjet systems and controlled droplet generation, where transient stability can be practically important. Classical analyses typically emphasize irreversible breakup of jets, and transient re-coalescence has received comparatively less experimental attention in simple gravity-driven systems.

Experimental Setup

For this experiment, a simple setup was arranged to produce a thin stream of water. The flow was carefully adjusted so that the water formed a very fine and narrow stream. Once the stream was stabilized, we introduced a stationary object (a hand) below it and gradually moved it upward until it was almost at the point of origin of the stream.

At this stage, reversible transition was observed:

• The continuous stream of water suddenly broke into discrete droplets.

• After about 1-2 seconds, these droplets re-merged into a continuous stream again.

• The cycle of stream-droplets-stream repeated more than once during the observation period, showing a spontaneous oscillatory nature.

Throughout this process, there was no external disturbance influencing the water flow. The only external element present was a stationary object (the hand).

This simple yet reproducible observation seems to suggest that a thin water stream, under the right conditions, may naturally switch between continuity and discreteness, creating a form of fluid oscillation.

Flow Rate of Water Stream

The volumetric flow rate was estimated by collecting approximately 10 mL of water over a duration of 5.51 s, yielding Q ≈ 1.81 x 10^-6  m³/s. This estimate is approximate and intended solely to characterize the order of magnitude of the flow conditions under which the phenomenon was observed.

Summary

A thin stream of water was generated from a stationary container under gravity. The flow rate was adjusted such that the stream remained narrow and continuous under normal conditions. No mechanical vibration, pressure modulation, or airflow was intentionally introduced.

A stationary object (hand) was placed beneath the stream and slowly raised toward the outlet, serving only as a passive boundary without contact or applied force. The experiment was recorded using a high-speed camera at 200 frames per second in 4K resolution to resolve rapid transitions.

The flow rate of the water is about 1.81 x 10^-6  m³/s.

Observation

The following sequence was consistently observed under stable, ambient conditions:

• The stream initially remained continuous.

• As the stationary object approached the origin of the stream, the jet spontaneously broke into discrete droplets.

• After approximately 1-2 seconds, the droplets began to re-merge downstream.

• A continuous stream re-formed without external intervention.

• The cycle repeated multiple times.

A time-resolved qualitative summary of the observations is provided in Table 1.

Table 1

Visual Evidence (in order)

Snapshot 1

Snapshot 2

Snapshot 3

Snapshot 4

Snapshot 5

Snapshot 6

Snapshot 7

Snapshot 8

Operational Regimes of the Water Stream

Based on repeated observations, the behavior of the water stream may be classified into three qualitative regimes depending on flow conditions and environmental stability. At relatively high flow rates and under stable ambient conditions, the stream remains continuous and does not exhibit breakup. At very low flow rates or under significant external disturbance, the stream breaks into discrete droplets without re-merging. Between these extremes, under moderate flow rates and minimal disturbance, a narrow regime is observed in which the stream exhibits reversible transitions between continuous and droplet-like states.

Analysis and Interpretation

The initial breakup of the jet is consistent with capillary instability mechanisms described by Rayleigh and later authors. However, the re-merging of droplets into a continuous stream is not typically emphasized in standard treatments, which often focus on irreversible breakup.

The observations suggest a dynamic balance and feedback between:

• Surface tension-driven instability promoting droplet formation

• Momentum continuity and gravitational acceleration promoting jet re-coalescence

  
  

Within a narrow flow regime, these competing effects may lead to a self-organized oscillatory behavior, rather than permanent fragmentation. Importantly, this interpretation does not challenge existing fluid-dynamical laws. Instead, it highlights a constrained operational regime that is rarely isolated in typical experiments.

Limitations and Failure Regimes

The observed phenomenon is not universal and fails outside specific conditions:

1. High flow rates: The jet remains continuous, suppressing capillary breakup.

2. Very low flow rates: The jet breaks into droplets without re-merging.

3. High-viscosity fluids: Fluids such as oils or honey do not exhibit this transition under normal conditions, as viscous forces dominate over surface tension.

4. External disturbances: Airflow, vibrations, pressure fluctuations, or deliberate perturbations suppress the transition.

These limitations define the domain of applicability of the observation.

Relation to Existing Theory

A natural question is whether reversible jet-droplet transitions contradict classical jet instability theory. They do not. The Rayleigh-Plateau framework predicts instability growth but does not preclude transient or dynamically stabilized regimes under finely tuned conditions. The present observation may therefore be interpreted as a special case within the broader theoretical framework, and is not intended to describe all liquid jets and makes no claim to supersede established instability theory.

Guiding Scientific Questions

This work raises testable questions:

• Under what precise flow-rate and diameter conditions does reversibility emerge?

• Can the oscillation frequency be quantitatively predicted?

• How does ambient pressure or fluid temperature affect the transition?

• Can numerical simulations reproduce the observed regime?

These questions define clear directions for future study.

Conclusion

This study reports a reproducible observation in which a thin water stream exhibits reversible transitions between continuous and droplet regimes under controlled conditions. While consistent with known capillary instability mechanisms, the behavior highlights a narrow parameter range where breakup is not permanent. The results do not challenge existing theory but suggest opportunities for deeper experimental and theoretical investigations into self-organized fluid dynamics. This work is intended as an exploratory observational study rather than a definitive theoretical model, and is presented to encourage further controlled investigation.

References

• Rayleigh, L. (1878). On the instability of jets. Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society, s1-10(1), 4–13. https://doi.org/10.1112/plms/s1-10.1.4.

• Eggers, J. (1997). Nonlinear dynamics and breakup of free-surface flows. Reviews of Modern Physics, 69(3), 865–930. https://doi.org/10.1103/revmodphys.69.865.

• Eggers, J., & Villermaux, E. (2008). Physics of liquid jets. Reports on Progress in Physics, 71(3), 036601. https://doi.org/10.1088/0034-4885/71/3/036601.

• Villermaux, E. (2006). Fragmentation. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 39(1), 419–446. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.fluid.39.050905.110214.

• Castrejón-Pita, J. R., Morrison, N. F., Harlen, O. G., Martin, G. D., & Hutchings, I. M. (2011). Experiments and Lagrangian simulations on the formation of droplets in continuous mode. Physical Review E, 83(1), 016301. https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.83.016301.

• Couder, Y., Fort, E., Gautier, C., & Boudaoud, A. (2005). From bouncing to floating: noncoalescence of drops on a fluid bath. Physical Review Letters, 94(17), 177801. https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.94.177801.

• Bush, J. W. (2014). Pilot-Wave Hydrodynamics. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 47(1), 269–292. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-fluid-010814-014506.